Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
Viewpoints: Public Health Lessons From Ending Our Smoking Culture
Not that long ago, cigarettes were completely woven into American culture. The Marlboro Man, posters telling us: 鈥淢ore doctors smoke Camels than any other cigarette,鈥 even the armrests on planes and all our cars were designed for smokers. And now? Not so much. Can it work like that with guns? Because after another horrific school shooting 鈥 eight students and two teachers massacred at Santa Fe High School outside Houston on Friday 鈥 we are nearly out of fresh ideas. (Petula Dvorak, 5/21)
It鈥檚 not enough religion, and too many violent video games. Those, we鈥檙e told, are the things causing America鈥檚 almost rhythmic school shootings. That鈥檚 where the blame was placed 鈥 again 鈥 this weekend as students and families and pundits and lawmakers grappled with Friday鈥檚 slaughter of 10 people at a high school in Santa Fe, Texas. ...The 鈥渙ur culture is causing mass shootings鈥 argument is compelling and can sound reasonable on a visceral level. But it鈥檚 based on emotion, not reality. (Rex Huppke, 5/21)
The National Rifle Association wants to make Friday鈥檚 high school shooting in Texas all about building security. The answer, as robotically recited by various officials, is to harden schools, establish airport-style security checkpoints, add more armed guards and allow teachers to pack heat. But apparently no number of young people鈥檚 corpses and grieving parents will move the organization to discuss the real issue: reducing shooters鈥 access to their mass-killing weapons of choice. (5/21)
A small medical device has just become embroiled in a large controversy, suggesting violations of fundamental ethical norms and settled principles of scientific research. At first glance, the Bridge 鈥 a neuro-modulation device that attaches behind the ear 鈥 resembles a hearing aid with wires. The Bridge received Food and Drug Administration (FDA) clearance in November 2017 for easing opioid withdrawal symptoms during detoxification; before, it was approved only for acupuncture. (Jody Lynee Madeira, 5/21)
The 鈥渞ight to try鈥 bill (S. 204), which suddenly resurfaced when the House scheduled it for committee meetings this week, was designed to allow patients with a terminal diagnosis 鈥 who have run out of effective treatment options 鈥 access to try a drug that just might help, even without Food and Drug Administration approval. This legislation 鈥 a priority for President Trump 鈥 sounds like a no-brainer. As the clock runs out, with a patient facing hospice as the next and last step, what could be wrong with giving an unproven drug a chance? Nothing, if it鈥檚 done right. (Mark M. Souweidane and Jeffrey P. Greenfield, 5/21)
My sister just finished 18 weeks of chemotherapy for ovarian cancer, a slog that started six months ago when she underwent an eight-hour procedure to remove all visible signs and cells of her malignancy. From the moment her primary-care doctor suspected the diagnosis, Julie鈥檚 calendar has been chock-full of appointments: scans, bloodwork, chemo treatments and a transfusion. Now that she鈥檚 done with chemo, Julie can either enroll in a clinical trial or sit tight and participate in what is called 鈥渨atchful waiting,鈥 which includes regular bloodwork, scans and doctor visits. I call it Hope. Pray. Wait. (Steven Petrow, 5/20)
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration recently announced a crackdown on e-cigarette sales to minors, but before then, the city of Chicago had already taken matters into its own hands. The City Council passed an ordinance to require tobacco dealers to post warning signs at their doors about the health risks of e-cigarettes and other tobacco products. These signs, once designed and distributed, will also contain quit-line numbers to help our residents beat a nicotine addiction.聽(Julie Morita, 5/21)
Florida Attorney General Pam Bondi鈥檚 lawsuit against the nation鈥檚 largest drug makers and distributors marks a moment of awakening in the state鈥檚 battle to recover from the opioid crisis. In blunt, forceful language, Bondi accuses these companies of sparking the deadly opioid epidemic through sham marketing that reaped the defendants 鈥渂illions of dollars鈥 while causing 鈥渋mmense harm to the state of Florida.鈥 This is an important step in holding an industry accountable for the incredible damage that has wracked communities and families. (5/22)
Trying to聽push more people to work for food stamps聽by adding harsh provisions to the farm bill has sharply divided Congress, even though the high-stakes bill failed to pass the U.S. House Friday, mostly over unrelated issues.聽Congress can take聽the food stamp work-requirement dispute off the table entirely. Instead of punitive, ill-considered measures likely to hurt hungry children, Congress should instead take aim at the unhealthy foods that are contributing to the obesity epidemic among our young people. (5/22)
A California Superior Court judge鈥檚 decision to strike down California鈥檚 鈥淓nd of Life Option Act鈥 is wrong as a matter of law. The California statute provides death with dignity for terminally ill patients. The California Court of Appeal should overturn this decision and failing that, the Legislature should quickly reenact it in a manner that addresses the judge鈥檚 concerns. (Erwin Chemerinsky, 5/21)