Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
Viewpoints: Pros And Cons Of Biogen's Decision To Reevaluate Alzheimer's Drug; Isn't It Really Time To Criminally Prosecute Companies Behind Opioid Epidemic?
One of the many things I鈥檝e learned during four decades of doing research on Alzheimer鈥檚 disease is that the work always brings surprises. Biogen鈥檚 announcement on Tuesday about its experimental Alzheimer鈥檚 drug, aducanumab, was a big one. ...Not long after Biogen鈥檚 decision to stop the trials, I wrote in Nature Reviews Neurology that when Biogen had a chance to look more closely at the data, it would likely observe some participants who benefited from aducanumab. At the time, I didn鈥檛 think the later analyses would be as good as what I heard Tuesday morning, which is that one of the two trials fully achieved its primary and secondary endpoints. (Dennis J. Selko, 10/23)
Biogen鈥檚 rescue mission is in part a different spin on the story;聽the company聽says its new data means that聽one of its trials should never聽have been labeled a failure in the first place.聽The聽attempt to put a positive spin on the second聽badly failed trial is the same sort of cherry-picking that gets drugmakers in trouble.聽The world badly needs an Alzheimer鈥檚 drug, and the company鈥檚 engagement with the聽FDA may mean the agency is inclined to be open-minded.聽Biogen still has聽an uphill battle to prove that it actually has one.聽(Max Nisen, 10/22)
Despite many promising leads, more than 120 drug treatments for Alzheimer鈥檚 disease have failed. But Cambridge-based biotech company Biogen revived hope on Tuesday with its announcement that it would seek Food and Drug Administration approval for a drug it abandoned earlier this year. Biogen鈥檚 experimental Alzheimer鈥檚 drug aducanumab targets beta-amyloid proteins that form plaque in the brain, which many scientists believe contributes to the debilitating disease. Investors and doctors considered Biogen鈥檚 drug the best hope in years for patients with early-stage Alzheimer鈥檚, and the FDA in 2016 granted it fast-track designation for approval. But Biogen in March abruptly suspended its drug trials after a 鈥渇utility analysis鈥 based on data from December indicated patients were unlikely to show meaningful improvement. That judgment may have been premature. (10/23)
Emily Walden鈥檚 son T.J. was 11 when he was first prescribed painkillers after breaking his arm. One prescription led to another, and by the time he was 18 he had become addicted to OxyContin. In an interview with The Courier-Journal of Louisville, Ky., Ms. Walden recalls him saying, 鈥淢om, I don鈥檛 want to die from this.鈥 In 2012, he did, at the age of 21. (Spencer Bokat-Lindell, 10/22)
Our failure to prioritize sexual health in the United States is making people sick, and for some of us it will be deadly.聽The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)聽released new data聽showing that STDs have reached record highs, after five straight years of increases. Most STDs can be treated, and many are curable, but if they go undetected, they can have life-changing and life-threatening consequences, including cancer, infertility, ectopic pregnancy, and increased risk for HIV. Thousands of Americans die every year as a result of STDs, even though every single one could be prevented.聽 (David C. Harvey, 10/22)
With costs rising painfully, insurance companies denying care聽and nearly 30 million people still uninsured, America desperately needs an honest health policy discussion. That鈥檚 why it has聽been so disappointing over the past several weeks to watch multiple candidates parrot right-wing attacks on "Medicare for All," like claiming that it will greatly increase spending on health care or ringing alarms about raising taxes聽on the middle class. The truth is the opposite: Medicare for All would sharply reduce overall spending on health care. (Donald M. Berwick, 10/22)
A great divide has appeared in the Democratic presidential primary between traditional candidates and populists who have latched onto proposals that sound great 鈥 at least to anyone who doesn鈥檛 do the math. The current frontrunner, Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.), is among the candidates trading on the proposed policy of 鈥淢edicare for All鈥 plan. Make no mistake: Medicare for All makes for a great soundbite but probably would never be approved even by a Democratic House, let alone a Republican Senate. (David Grazzo, 10/21)
This past week the聽U.S. District Court in D.C. refused to modify聽its September decision聽that found CMS鈥 2019 expansion of its Medicare site neutral payment policy illegal. Instead of appealing the decision, CMS should rethink how the Medicare program can become a prudent purchaser of health-care services.聽聽The Medicare site-neutral payments were based on a聽2012 MedPAC recommendation聽that CMS made payments the same between higher paid hospital outpatient departments (HOPDs) and lesser-paid freestanding physician offices. (David Introcaso, 10/23)
I became an obstetrician-gynecologist 20 years ago because I wanted to be a source of compassion and expertise for patients and their families as they navigate a wide range of reproductive experiences, including when they seek abortion care. I wanted to be someone my patients could turn to when others might abandon or judge them. (Lisa H. Harris, 10/22)
California Atty. Gen. Xavier Becerra鈥檚 many lawsuits against the Trump administration are policy fights, at the simplest level 鈥 legal battles by a blue state to impede a Republican president鈥檚 deregulatory and socially conservative agenda.But a more interesting subtext is the work by California and its allies to limit the power of the federal government, and in particular the executive branch of the federal government. (John Healey, 10/22)