Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
Viewpoints: Government Control Of Drug Prices Is A Bad Idea For Patients; Lessons On How Medicare Advantage Helps Ease Opioid Crisis
With a new Democratic majority in the House pledging to address the rising cost of health care 鈥 including prescription drugs 鈥 a fundamental question arises: Will lawmakers focus on the real issues that can drain a family鈥檚 finances, or simply adopt extreme policies that fail to take on the underlying problems in our health care system? As policy professionals from different sides of the aisle, we believe there is a right way to address these issues and a wrong way. The right way will reduce out-of-pocket costs for Americans, improve access to new medicines, and allow the United States to remain the global leader in medical innovation. The wrong way leads to price controls, weakened intellectual property protections, and restricted access to medicines, not to mention stifling innovation and doing little to make drugs more affordable. (Jim Greenwood and David Beier, 12/20)
The Trump administration wants to use an average of the drug prices paid by other countries to limit what Medicare Part B pays for some drugs. This is a bad idea. Pricing reflects preferences, and the Trump administration plan would replace the needs of American patients with the preferences of foreign bureaucrats. (Linda Gorman, 12/19)
Since most of Medicare Advantage provides both drug and medical insurance, the authors surmise that the insurance plans have a stronger incentive to mitigate opioid problems. As the authors argue, the Medicare Advantage plans have 鈥渢he incentive to account for the spillover effects of prescription drug use on the cost of care overall and can choose which physicians to include in its network and how it manages care.鈥 Stand-alone plans providing only Part D drug coverage, by contrast, do not face the same incentives, since the cost of addressing medical problems is not their responsibility.聽(Peter R. Orszag, 12/19)
A recent Gallup poll notes that three in 10 Americans delayed seeking medical care due to cost 鈥 a true testament as to why America needs to solve its health-care access crisis.The notion that approximately 19 percent of all U.S. adults delayed treatment for serious or somewhat serious conditions or illness carries serious consequences particularly for diseases such as cancer, cardiovascular disease and a myriad of other acute and chronic conditions that may be amenable to early diagnosis and treatment. (Janice Phillips and Maria Alonso, 12/19)
After a career spent in pharmaceutical commercial strategy and operations, I thought I had a handle on what was required to launch a new therapy. But I鈥檝e learned many lessons 鈥 and faced a few curveballs 鈥 in the 12 months since the FDA approved Luxturna (voretigene neparvovec), a one-time gene therapy for the treatment of patients with vision loss due to inherited retinal dystrophy caused by confirmed biallelic RPE65 mutations and who have sufficient viable retinal cells. (Ron Philip, 12/19)
All of this research, combined with the Reuter鈥檚 report, makes me hesitant to recommend regular, heavy use of talcum powder for either babies or women. I am not alone in such caution. I would say to be aware of a possible associated risk and to be judicious in your use. At the same time, since I am anything but a fear-monger, I will gladly reassure patients who have been exposed to daily talcum powder use that the risk of developing cancer from it remains extremely small. (Marc Siegel, 12/19)
I come from a long line of combat veterans who have taken up arms to defend this nation since before George Washington crossed the Delaware, and I spent decades in the military myself. So I understand why these kinds of weapons exist.But what I don鈥檛 get is why semiautomatics that U.S. service members carry around Fallujah are being sold to teenagers at the corner gun store.What I don鈥檛 understand is how some politicians can consider the National Rifle Association鈥檚 dollars more important than our kids鈥 lives.Or how our streets have become deadlier than war zones, with more Americans killed by gun violence over the past 50 years than in every war in American history combined. (Sen. Tammy Duckworth, 12/19)
As a physician and lawmaker, I have long argued that federal global health aid improves America鈥檚 standing in the world and makes us safer by steadying unstable nations. Countries with healthy workforces have improved economic outputs, stronger family units, and are less likely to become havens for terrorists.聽 But what many may not realize is that the health of our population here at home also impacts our national security.聽(Bill Frist, 12/19)
Burnout is a real thing. Vacations and breaks, even coffee breaks, make us more productive and more engaged with both our work and our day-to-day life. However, to say all that already plays into the dominant narrative that we need to rationalize our time away from work as good for the work, and our desire that we not live on scraps alone as something bigger than a simple desire to relax and enjoy our life. It鈥檚 a set of beliefs so dominant even Ocasio-Cortez felt impelled to make a nod to it. So let me say this: It is the holidays and the end of the year. We can all rest and enjoy ourselves 鈥 for any reason we want. (Helaine Olen, 12/19)
A proposed redefinition of gender as a 鈥渂iological, immutable condition determined by a person鈥檚 genitalia at birth鈥 would have damaging repercussions for vulnerable communities that have faced discrimination from health care providers, hospitals, insurers, and others. (Jocelyn Samuels and Mara Keisling, 12/19)
As our society鈥檚 concept of gender evolves, so does the visibility of contemporary nonbinary people. Yet many members of the medical community may not know how to interact with nonbinary patients respectfully or recognize their unique needs and barriers to care. (Walter Liszewski, J. Klint Peebles, Howa Yeung, and Sarah Arron, 12/20)
鈥淚f a man says he is a woman, does that mean he is mentally ill?鈥 The staff member asking this question was attending a mandatory training session on health care for sexual and gender minority (SGM) patients at an urban hospital. She spoke timidly and seemed genuinely curious. We explained that incongruence between the sex assigned at birth and gender identity 鈥 denoted by the term 鈥渢ransgender鈥 鈥 is not a mental illness, and that transgender people鈥檚 mental health often improves with care that affirms their gender identity. She thanked us for the explanation, and we moved to the next topic, but her question lingered in our minds. We were surprised that concepts we took for granted were unknown to this clinician, who practiced in a large, diverse medical center. And yet questions such as hers are becoming more common as continuing medical education on SGM health expands. (Kevin L. Ard and Alex S. Keuroghlian, 12/20)
What if homeless people were provided with more comfortable sleeping environments, where they could get the rest required to function better? Would homelessness then be reduced? I definitely think so. After all, without the clarity that a decent night鈥檚 sleep provides, how can someone climb the herculean mountain of self-sufficiency that housing oneself demands? (Lori Teresa Yearwood, 12/19)