Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
Viewpoints: Get Behind Doctors' Advice About Reducing Carnage Caused By Guns; New Exercise Guidelines Lack Muscle
We never thought we would see the National Rifle Association help advance the discussion of gun violence as a public-health crisis. But that is exactly what the organization unwittingly did when it essentially told doctors they had no business talking about guns and should just shut up. What followed instead was an indignant outpouring of heart-rending stories from professionals who see close up the horror and damage caused by guns. (11/13)
To the mother whose son I couldn鈥檛 save: I wish that I possessed some combination of words that could heal the wound in your heart, some turn of phrase that could end your sorrow. But I have no such words. You will live the rest of your life with an unfillable void and the simple question 鈥渨hy?鈥 forever unanswered. (Jaques Mather, 11/13)
Public heath advocates appear to be getting desperate over the state of Americans鈥 inactivity.The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services on Monday released a new set of physical activity guidelines and they are...ah...interesting. Instead of prescribing the standard block of sustained physical activity 鈥 previously at least 10 minutes at a time 鈥 the government is now urging Americans to, you know, move around more during the day and sit less. (Mariel Garza, 11/14)
Responses to a nationwide survey indicated that while most Americans are aware of the dangers posed by infections that have grown increasingly resistant to current antibiotic treatments, only about half know enough about the correct use of antibiotics to prevent resistance from occurring.聽As a physician, I have had to hope that patients鈥 immune systems could fill the gap left by failing treatments against antibiotic-resistant infections. As the president of the Infectious Diseases Society of America, which, with Research!America, commissioned the survey, the responses both encourage and alarm me. (Cynthia Sears, 11/13)
A critical test for the Trump administration is whether to drop support for a frivolous lawsuit to invalidate the ACA, currently being pushed by 20 Republican state attorneys general. If that lawsuit continues, expect the voters who became so active this year to keep health care on the front burner.When it comes to 2020, Republicans would prefer to make the next election a referendum on single payer health care, such as Medicare for All, than on the ACA and pre-existing conditions. That will be a tough sell, particularly if they are continuing to attack the ACA. (Andy Slavitt, 11/14)
Our聽new polling聽also revealed a more troubling trend: nearly three-quarters (72 percent) of 18-29 year olds report being聽concerned that women may not be able to access the full range of birth control methods in the future because of today鈥檚 political landscape. Their聽concerns are justified.聽Over the past year,聽the current administration has been relentless in its pursuit to limit聽access to no or low cost birth control.聽(Ginny Ehrlich, 11/13)
HHS promises to push for alternatives to the use of fetal tissue in research. But other approaches 鈥 including adult stem cells 鈥 don鈥檛 work as well. Fetal cells are less differentiated, and therefore more flexible, than adult cells. And tissue from elective abortions, unlike that from miscarriages, is easier to obtain under controlled conditions, and less likely to contain developmental abnormalities.Elective abortions, of course, are what the activists want to stop: They believe fetal-tissue research encourages them. (11/13)
As Greg Lukianoff and Jonathan Haidt chronicle in their new book, 鈥淭he Coddling of the American Mind,鈥 today鈥檚 young people tend to be obsessed with safety, troubled by a pervasive sense of threat. Consequently, understandably, they鈥檙e anxious and depressed. ...In an Atlantic article headlined 鈥淐ollege Is Different for the School-Shooting Generation,鈥 Ashley Fetters describes a rising generation that constantly scans rooms for exit points and games out active-shooter scenarios. (Megan McArdle, 11/13)
State measures implemented about three years ago to improve vaccine education have caused the number of non-medical vaccine waivers to drop and vaccination rates to rise in Michigan. Yet聽the 15 recent confirmed cases of measles prove that聽those who refuse vaccines 鈥 or to vaccinate their children 鈥斅燾ontinue to risk both their health and the health of the state. Measles is spread by direct person-to-person contact, and through the air by a contagious person sneezing or coughing.聽Germs can live for up to two hours. (11/13)
Building housing is a long, slow affair. It鈥檚 even slower when developers are building housing for homeless people. Just cobbling together financing from myriad sources can take up to two years, and then there鈥檚 the permitting, the political haggling, the inevitable negotiations with neighbors. So it鈥檚 encouraging to see two different attempts to speed up this lumbering process. (11/14)