Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
Viewpoints: Don't Let Measles Draw Down Our Resources For Responding To Large-Scale Problems; Outlawing Private Insurance Is Too Radical
A devastating infectious disease pandemic could kill more people than nuclear war. Just 100 years ago, the Spanish flu killed 50 to 100 million people. Life-threatening diseases continue to place us at great risk. Ten years ago, it was H1N1 influenza. Today, it is the measles. Last聽week, New York Mayor Bill de Blasio declared a public health emergency. Measles outbreaks are occurring in New York City and throughout the nation,聽with聽case counts rising at an alarming rate.聽The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention聽reports 555 confirmed cases聽in 20 states so far this year. It is the second-highest total since measles, which is highly contagious,聽was declared eliminated聽in the Americas聽almost two decades ago.聽(Joe Lieberman and Tom Ridge, 4/16)
U.S. senator and presidential candidate Bernie Sanders recently released his health-care plan, which he calls 鈥淢edicare for All.鈥 With a name like that, one would think that the proposal involves extending the Medicare system, which provides health-care insurance to the elderly, to all Americans. But Sanders鈥檚 plan is something different. It would outlaw most forms of private health insurance and eliminate all out-of-pocket costs 鈥 something that Medicare doesn鈥檛 now do. (Noah Smith, 4/15)
Drug companies, for-profit hospitals, insurance companies聽and others invested in profit-based care are campaigning vigorously against single-payer, spreading misinformation and fearmongering. Industry-aligned anti-single-payer individuals are posing as ordinary citizens spreading misinformation about single-payer.Don鈥檛 believe the lies. National health plans work extraordinarily well in every other industrialized nation. Canada, Scotland, Sweden, Taiwan,聽and Japan (among dozens of others) cover their entire population for a fraction of what the U.S. spends (wastes!) and enjoy longer lifespans and better health outcomes. How will we pay for it? An American single-payer plan will pay for itself by redirecting wasted administration and profiteering funds into patient care. Consider the vast difference in cost: From 2007 to 2014, spending in private plans grew nearly 17 percent per enrollee, while Medicare spending decreased 1.2聽percent per beneficiary. (Garrett Adams, 4/15)
In Donald Trump鈥檚 two-plus years as president, his approach to policymaking has often been defined by an unsavory stew of indecision, inaction, flip-flops and outright lies.Nowhere has this been truer than with health care, where the administration has reversed direction multiple times. (Steven Rattner, 4/15)
Last week, reports emerged of how a U.K.-based manufacturer called Britax avoided recalling a line of dangerous jogging strollers by politically gaming the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC). Even after countless incidents of product malfunctions that led to serious injuries, these strollers remain on the market, placing families and young children at risk. The Britax jogging strollers aren鈥檛 the only risky product making recent headlines. Intense media pressure has finally led to a recall of Fisher-Price Rock n鈥 Play Sleepers, a childcare product that has reportedly been tied to more than 30 infant fatalities. Meanwhile, the Britax strollers are still on the market and it is unclear how many other dangerous products have escaped further scrutiny to remain available to consumers along with them. (David Oddo, 4/15)
There鈥檚 been a lot of talk about overinvestment in interventions aimed at amyloid in the weeks since Biogen discontinued a late-stage study of aducanumab, an experimental therapy for Alzheimer鈥檚 disease.Although much of the focus has been on the amyloid hypothesis at the heart of that work 鈥 and other failed treatments 鈥 I believe we are overlooking another key driver for numerous translational failures: the overreliance on behavioral readouts from contrived transgenic rodent models to guide drug development for Alzheimer鈥檚, Parkinson鈥檚, and other neurologic diseases. We need to find ways to move beyond this flawed paradigm. (Adam Rosenberg, 4/16)