Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
Viewpoints: Doctors Need To Stop Saying No To Patients Who Need Opioids; FDA's E-Cigarette Policies Could Make It Tough On U.S. Troops
Patients in pain have become collateral damage in the war on opioids. That鈥檚 the message of a letter from more than 300 medical professionals, including three former White House drug czars, to the Centers for Disease Control. In 2016, the CDC issued guidelines to discourage doctors from overprescribing opioids. The signatories believe that those guidelines are being misapplied in a way that keeps many patients in agony. (Ramesh Ponnuru, 3/21)
In the politically-charged climate of 2019, there are very few things that our society can universally agree on. Some of the few things we can agree on, however, is that smoking cigarettes is bad for one鈥檚 health, and that even when we don鈥檛 support a war, we will support the troops. Therefore, it should logically follow that anything that aids active duty service members and military veterans to quit smoking in order to live longer, happier lives, should be encouraged. 聽Unfortunately, this is where our politically charged climate returns. Despite scientific evidence that the use of electronic cigarettes, commonly known as 鈥渧aping,鈥 are 鈥渟ignificantly more effective than nicotine replacement treatments鈥 such as patches, gum or other forms of oral nicotine in getting people to quit smoking, the FDA recently proposed a rule prohibiting the sale of e-cigarettes to places where children under the age of 18 can enter. (Rory E. Riley-Topping, 3/21)
This month, Eli Lilly and Company announced with some fanfare that it was manufacturing a generic version of its own best-selling insulin brand, Humalog, which it would sell for half off 鈥 $137.35 versus about $275. David Ricks, the chief executive of Lilly, said the company was making this seemingly beneficent gesture because 鈥渕any patients are struggling to afford their insulin.鈥 But they鈥檙e struggling, in large part, because since 2001 Lilly has raised the price of a vial of Humalog to about $275, from $35. Other insulin makers have raised prices similarly. (Elisabeth Rosenthal, 3/21)
New Zealand banned semi-automatic rifles this week, and made the ban effective immediately to prevent 鈥渟tockpiling of weapons while the legislation is being drafted.鈥 The Kiwis are apparently not big on the 鈥渉opes and prayers鈥 mantra that the U.S. Congress adopts聽after each gun massacre.聽(Francis Wilkinson, 3/21)
Over the past two presidential administrations, political fury has swirled around the nation鈥檚 health-care system. Health care is almost always at the top of the list of America鈥檚 domestic policy concerns. As well, it should be. But without addressing the nation鈥檚 growing housing crisis, an efficient and humane health system will stay out of reach. Health-care delivery systems recognize this. In a few cases, large hospitals, health plans and even insurance companies now are putting resources into housing for patients. It is time for public policy makers to recognize the absurdity of ignoring the most critical social determinant for good health outcomes: safe housing. (Robert M. Hayes, 3/21)
I鈥檝e been sharing my cellphone number since I started my practice in 2009. Most of my paid clinical time is spent rushing through 15-minute visits and slogging through electronic paperwork. With texting, the rush disappears. Patients can text me when they want and there are no boxes to tick. (Clement Bottino, 3/22)
Technically, the voice is a baritone. Some say it鈥檚 definitely fake 鈥 another part of the same old scam. Others say there鈥檚 no way of knowing. But the impossibility of an answer rarely stops the truly curious from trying to find one. And Elizabeth Holmes鈥檚 voice has become an obsession.No one has been able to crack Holmes so far. Not in a book, not in a podcast and not in two documentaries, the second of which came out this week. The accused Silicon Valley con woman, who lost investors hundreds of millions of dollars as she allegedly propelled a colossal lie to a $9 billion valuation, is a riddle wrapped in a blank-faced, unblinking enigma. Those who want to understand the woman have to start somewhere, and why not her most distinctive feature? (Molly Robert, 3/21)
Scientists can鈥檛, for the most part, prove that聽a given product caused a particular person to get cancer 鈥 not the way you can prove, say, that a car with faulty brakes caused a fatal crash. And so when a federal jury in San Francisco District Court decided that the weed killer Roundup was a 鈥渟ubstantial factor鈥 in causing someone to get a type of cancer called non-Hodgkins lymphoma, they didn鈥檛 actually have proof for the individual case. What they had was evidence that the product was a probable factor in the man鈥檚 cancer, based on studies that follow large populations.Of course science should be the deciding factor in such cases, but there鈥檚 no sense in implying that scientists can do the impossible. What scientists and society at large have come to agree upon is that it鈥檚 reasonable to award people compensation if it鈥檚 more likely than not that they would have avoided the cancer if they鈥檇 been able to avoid the product in question. (Faye Flam, 3/21)
When Canada legalized cannabis last fall, the country began blazing a trail that the U.S. should one day follow. There鈥檚 much to emulate about the Canadian government鈥檚 approach to legalization, and a few things to avoid, but having marijuana legalized on such a large scale so close to home will no doubt have a profound effect on America鈥檚 future treatment of the issue. Medical or recreational marijuana is now legal in 33 U.S. states, even though its possession or use is illegal under federal law. (Lyle Hauser, 3/22)
A train wreck that everyone sees coming still hurts.聽Biogen Inc. announced Thursday that it was discontinuing late-stage studies of its Alzheimer鈥檚 medicine aducanumab. That shouldn鈥檛 be a huge surprise: Every other drug attempting to treat Alzheimer鈥檚 the same way 鈥斅燽y targeting the buildup of amyloid beta plaques in the brain 鈥斅爃as failed.聽(Max Nisen, 3/21)