Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
Viewpoints: Are Vaccine Passports The Key To Travel?; Can Employers Legally Mandate Vaccination?
After more than a year of sheltering聽at home, people are itching to travel internationally聽again 鈥 especially those who鈥檝e been聽sitting on credits from trips canceled in 2020. Airlines would like nothing more than to see borders reopened. While the industry聽supports continued mask mandates, physical distancing and other safety measures, they are banking on vaccinations聽to loosen聽the more cumbersome international testing and quarantine requirements. In the U.S., the airline industry聽has called on the Biden administration to update Centers for Disease Control and Prevention guidance to exempt vaccinated international travelers from current Covid聽testing requirements. In Europe, Michael O鈥橪eary, the CEO of Ryanair Holdings Plc,聽argues that the litmus tests for maintaining travel restrictions should be hospitalizations and deaths. 鈥淥nce you鈥檝e eliminated that risk with vaccinations, frankly I think people are going to rebel. They鈥檙e not going to be willing to be locked up,鈥澛燨鈥橪eary said in an interview with Bloomberg TV last month. 鈥淐ovid will become 鈥 I mean it will still be with us 鈥 but it will be much more I think similar to the annual flu, the annual cold, because of the success of vaccinations.鈥 (Brooke Sutherland and Sam Fazeli, 4/5)
Covid-19 vaccines offer a way out of the global crisis that has upended 鈥 and cut short 鈥 lives for more than a year. Three vaccines have now received emergency use authorization (EUA) from the FDA. One question that employers and universities must rapidly consider and act upon is whether to mandate that returning employees and students be vaccinated. Some employers are starting to require Covid-19 vaccines, and Rutgers University became the first university to mandate them for students and employees. (Dorit R. Reiss, I. Glenn Cohen and Carmel Shachar, 4/5)
In the next couple of months, America鈥檚 vaccination program is likely to undergo a radical shift. Suddenly gone will be today鈥檚 world of vaccine scarcity, where the anxious and eager spend hours scouring the Web for elusive appointments. We will enter the land of vaccine overabundance, where public health officials prod, wheedle and beg hesitant adults to please come in and get their shots. At that point, we鈥檒l collectively confront questions that have mostly been theoretical: What鈥檚 the best way to overcome the understandable anxiety of those who worry about undetected dangers of novel vaccine technologies? How do we locate vaccination centers to be convenient for people in rural areas? Most controversial will be this question: What circumstances justify requiring vaccination? Can it be mandatory for someone to work in a nursing home, enroll in a public school, attend a concert, get on an airplane? Which is to say, how much risk should the rest of us have to accept to respect the conscience rights and bodily autonomy of fellow citizens who don鈥檛 want to get vaccinated? (Megan McArdle, 4/3)
As more people are vaccinated against COVID-19, some wonder about the reason for government tracking vaccinations. Currently, every state maintains a vaccine registry, which has been vital infrastructure to our public health. It is a resource for our citizens, enabling them to not have to keep paper vaccination records, which can easily be lost through natural disasters or moving, or to track down previous vaccine providers who may have closed their offices. A state registry also provides information for health care professionals to target therapies or interventions to prevent the spread of infectious diseases while working to maintain privacy for our citizens. Federal and state regulations already require COVID-19 vaccine administration to be reported to ImmTrac2, the Texas state registry used to track all vaccinations. This is the only way for state and federal health officials to know when we鈥檝e reached a point where enough people are protected from disease, that the spread of COVID-19 will be minimized, preventing unnecessary illness and deaths. Additionally, knowing which populations are and aren鈥檛 vaccinated helps uncover any disparities in access or distribution. ( Dr. Seth D. Kaplan, Dr. Jason V. Terk, Dr. Joyce Mauk and Dr. Sandra McKay, 4/5)
Also 鈥
Black Americans have died of COVID-19 at much higher rates than white Americans. It is well understood that the driver of these racial disparities is racism and social inequality, not genetics. In contrast, many researchers have assumed that sex disparities in COVID-19 mortality are largely due to differences in biology. Our research challenges this narrative about COVID-19 sex differences. COVID-19 offers an example of how a focus on male-female sex differences, without looking at intersecting variables, can obscure important determinants of individual risk. (Tamara Rushovich and Sarah S. Richardson, 4/5)
I don鈥檛 know about you, but I鈥檝e found the latest stage of the pandemic hard in its own distinct way. The cumulative effect of a year of repetition, isolation and stress has induced a lassitude 鈥 a settling into the familiar, with feelings of vulnerability. The shock of a year ago has been replaced by a sluggish just-getting-to-the-end. I鈥檝e got the same scattered memory issues many others in this Groundhog Day life describe: walking into a room and wondering why I went there; spending impressive amounts of time looking for my earbuds; forgetting the names of people and places outside my COVID bubble. (David Brooks, 4/5)
It鈥檚 been four weeks since I received my second dose of the COVID-19 vaccine, but very little has changed for me. I鈥檓 still living in pandemic mode. The only difference is that when I鈥檓 out for a walk, I no longer step off the sidewalk and onto the street when I approach someone who鈥檚 not wearing a mask. Turns out, 鈥渃ave mentality鈥 is a thing. Though we show off our vaccine cards like a winning lottery ticket, many people are reluctant to venture back into the world. One of my friends recently declared that she鈥檚 never going to eat in a restaurant again. I鈥檓 not taking it that far, though. I鈥檓 looking forward to doing fun things again 鈥 just not today or tomorrow. That might not be such a bad thing since federal health officials are warning us about 鈥渋mpending doom鈥 from a potential fourth surge of the virus. (Dahleen Glanton, 4/5)