Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
The Rocky Road Back To School: Vaccine Gag Rule, Mask Wars
Employees in a northwestern Arizona school district cannot discuss vaccination status or mask-wearing with students under a motion approved unanimously by the local school board. The edict from the Colorado River Union High School District Governing Board carries no repercussions for administrators, staff or teachers who violate it. That would be up to Superintendent Monte Silk, who supported the motion. (8/20)
Gov. Kevin Stitt and Attorney General John O'Connor reprimanded聽a small eastern Oklahoma school district for its strict masking policy on Thursday聽鈥斅燼 day after the federal government admonished the state for discouraging mask mandates in schools. Stitt and O'Connor said聽Hulbert Public Schools violated聽state law Wednesday night聽when its school board voted in favor of a masking requirement for all students and staff.聽(Martinez-Keel, 8/19)
Millions of students in Florida, Texas and Arizona are now required to wear masks in class as school boards in mostly Democratic areas have defied their Republican governors and made face coverings mandatory. The three states are all hot spots in the nation鈥檚 recent COVID-19 surge, and defiant boards in Miami, Dallas, Houston, Phoenix and other urban areas argue that requiring masks protects students, teachers and staff from contracting and spreading the virus as many pediatric hospitals fill. (Spencer, 8/20)
In news on the impact of rules and policies during the pandemic 鈥
Conflicting policies, fiery political debates and the continued spread of the Delta variant of COVID-19 are sowing chaos and uncertainty into the back-to-school season. This will be the third school year in a row with COVID-related disruptions. Many students have already suffered severe learning loss, and the gap between students could grow even wider, thanks to disparities in vaccinations and rising case counts. (8/20)
KHN: School Or 鈥楻ussian Roulette鈥? Amid Delta Variant And Lax Mask Rules, Some Parents See No Difference聽
The child had just started kindergarten. Or, as her mother called it, 鈥淩ussian roulette.鈥 That鈥檚 because her school district in Grand Junction, Colorado, experienced one of the nation鈥檚 first delta-variant outbreaks last spring, and now school officials have loosened the rules meant to protect against covid-19. The mother, Venessa, who asked not to be named in full for fear of repercussions for her family, is part of a group of parents, grandparents, medical professionals and community members who assembled in the past few weeks to push back. The group calls itself 鈥淪.O.S.,鈥 which stands for 鈥淪upporters for Open and Safe Schools,鈥 while nodding to the international signal for urgent help. It鈥檚 made up of Republicans and Democrats, Christians and atheists, and its main request: Require masks. (Bichell, 8/20)
New Mexico鈥檚 top education official during the pandemic headed into his final days in Santa Fe saying outdoor classrooms could have allowed more in-person instruction when schools were closed last year and may be key to addressing parents鈥 masking concerns. Education Secretary Ryan Stewart leaves on Friday, two years into his term, citing the need to be near family as his father faces serious illness. (Attanasio, 8/20)
Mississippi Gov. Tate Reeves said Thursday that his goal is to keep as many schools open as possible, even as COVID-19 cases continue to rise sharply in the state, because he does not want children to lose academic advancement. Reeves, a Republican, said local school districts have the power to offer vaccinations to children 12 and older, with parents鈥 permission. He said school districts also can set mask mandates or require students to maintain distance from one another to mitigate the spread of the airborne virus. (Wagster Pettus, 8/19)
Also 鈥
Carrie Underwood, one of country music鈥檚 most popular superstars, generally does not generate controversy. That changed this week with the click of a button. On Tuesday, a screenshot started making its way around Twitter that showed Underwood鈥檚 account 鈥渓iked鈥 a Twitter video posted by conservative commentator Matt Walsh. The video showed Walsh speaking at a recent contentious school board meeting over a mask mandate for Metro Nashville Public Schools, likening mask requirements for kids to child abuse and saying that more children have died of the flu than covid-19. He argued that the mask mandate was politically motivated and students鈥 masks are a 鈥渟ymbolic security blanket.鈥 (Yahr, 8/19)