Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
Texas Appeals Judge's Temporary Block Of Law Banning Most Abortions
A federal judge temporarily blocked Texas鈥 near-total abortion ban Wednesday as part of a lawsuit the Biden administration launched against the state over its new law that bars abortions as early as six weeks of pregnancy. But it鈥檚 unclear how U.S. District Judge Robert Pitman鈥檚 order may affect access to abortions in the state 鈥 or if it will at all. The state of Texas quickly filed a notice of appeal and will almost definitely seek an emergency stay of Pitman's order in the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals, which is known as perhaps the nation鈥檚 most conservative appellate court. (Oxner, 10/6)
In a 113-page opinion, Judge Robert Pitman barred state judges and court clerks from hearing lawsuits against abortion providers and others who help women obtain the procedure after about six weeks of pregnancy. The law requires private citizens, not state officials, to enforce the new guidelines through litigation in state courts. The decision was quickly appealed by state leaders. In a seething conclusion, Pitman also denied the state鈥檚 request to delay any injunction until it has a chance to appeal, writing it had 鈥渇orfeited the right鈥 by concocting such an obviously unconstitutional law in the first place. Women have had constitutional access to abortion since 1973. (Blackman and Goldenstein, 10/7)
The White House and the Justice Department praised the decision. 鈥淭onight鈥檚 ruling is an important step forward toward restoring the constitutional rights of women across the state of Texas,鈥 said White House press secretary Jen Psaki. She added: 鈥淭he fight has only just begun, both in Texas and in many states across this country where women鈥檚 rights are currently under attack.鈥 (Gerstein and Ollstein, 10/6)
Amy Hagstrom Miller, founder of Whole Woman鈥檚 Health, said the organization鈥檚 four abortion clinics would immediately resume procedures up to 18 weeks of pregnancy. After the law went into effect, the clinics were having to turn away some 80% of patients seeking abortions, Ms. Miller said previously. Wednesday evening, she called the judge鈥檚 ruling amazing. 鈥淚t鈥檚 the justice we鈥檝e been seeking for weeks,鈥 Ms. Miller said. Kimberlyn Schwartz, the spokeswoman for Texas Right to Life, said the organization wasn鈥檛 surprised by the ruling and called the injunction unprecedented. 鈥淲e expect a fair shake at the Fifth Court of Appeals,鈥 Ms. Schwartz said. 鈥淭he legacy of Roe v. Wade is you have these judges that will bend over to cater to the abortion industry.鈥 (Kendall, 10/6)
Also 鈥
In the wording of the new law, abortions in Texas are prohibited once medical professionals can detect cardiac activity, usually around six weeks and before some women know they鈥檙e pregnant. Enforcement is left up to private citizens who are deputized to file civil lawsuits against abortion providers, as well as others who help a woman obtain an abortion in Texas. Supporters of the law known as Senate Bill 8 were preparing for a ruling that favors the Justice Department鈥檚 challenge but believe the measure 鈥 the strictest abortion law in the nation 鈥 will ultimately be upheld. Texas officials swiftly told the court Wednesday of their intention to seek a reversal. (Weber and Gresko, 10/7)
Attorney General Maura Healey, who was one of 24 state attorneys general to file a brief in support of the justice department鈥檚 lawsuit, applauded Pitman. She called the law 鈥渁 blatantly unconstitutional scheme to undermine鈥 the Supreme Court鈥檚 decision in Roe v. Wade that has guaranteed access to abortion for almost half a century. 鈥淔or weeks, patients in Texas have been forced to travel thousands of miles to nearby states to access safe, legal abortion,鈥 Healey said in a statement. 鈥淭hey have driven in the dead of night in secret, for fear of bounty hunters chasing their friends and families. Those who cannot afford the trip have been forced into pregnancy by the state of Texas, forever altering the course of their lives. (Fox, 10/6)
In other abortion news from Kentucky 鈥
Kentucky鈥檚 Republican attorney general laid out his strategy Wednesday to champion his state鈥檚 embattled abortion law in court, calling his office the 鈥渓ast line of defense鈥 for the measure that would block a second-trimester procedure to end pregnancies. Attorney General Daniel Cameron said his first goal is to persuade the U.S. Supreme Court to let him defend the 2018 law, which was previously struck down by lower courts. The Supreme Court agreed to hear the procedural dispute and scheduled a hearing next Tuesday. (Schreiner, 10/6)