Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
Perspectives: When It Comes To Health Care, Watch What Republicans Do Not What They Say
President Trump chose this paper to make his case that Republicans are the party to be trusted and the Democrats are to be feared when it comes to your health care. Polls suggest Americans don鈥檛 see it that way. If they鈥檙e smart, they will pay attention to votes, not quotes (or op-eds) from politicians and look at what鈥檚 likely to happen in health care after next month鈥檚 election. So let鈥檚 take a look at what is likely to happen based on who carries the midterms. (Andy Slavitt, 10/12)
In November of every even-numbered year since at least 1970, the biggest lie in American politics has been Democrats claiming that Republicans are going to take away your Social Security. Republicans learned to live in a defensive crouch and to try to avoid mentioning the words 鈥淪ocial Security.鈥 Now the new lie is about health care, mostly that Republicans are going to take away coverage for聽preexisting conditions. As usual, the truth is very different. The Senate Republican Policy Committee explained in a May 2017 paper that under the Republican-backed alternative to Obamacare, the American Health Care Act, 鈥渘o one will be denied coverage because of a pre-existing condition.鈥 Even if you are skeptical of Republican talking points, you don鈥檛 have to look very far to find objective confirmation. According to FactCheck.org, 鈥淪en. [Charles E.] Schumer [D-N.Y.] 鈥 was wrong to say, as he did on the Senate floor April 28, that the bill goes 鈥榖ack to the day when insurance companies could deny coverage to those with preexisting conditions.鈥 鈥 (Ed Rogers, 10/11)
Iowans have now received what the Republican-controlled state Legislature and Gov. Kim Reynolds ordered: the option to聽buy聽unregulated health plans that can deny coverage, suddenly cancel plans, not pay medical bills and face no repercussions.聽The Iowa Farm Bureau last week unveiled details about its new health plans, which聽are supposed to offer an alternative to policies that must comply with requirements in the Affordable Care Act. These "health benefit plans"聽are not health insurance, not subject to聽basic coverage requirements and not regulated by any state or federal entity.聽(Des Moines Register, 10/10)
In baseball, the winning pitcher is the one who was on the mound just before聽his team took聽the lead for good 鈥斅爎egardless of how well he pitched. So a reliever who gets hammered, turning a three-run lead into a two-run deficit,聽nevertheless will get聽credit for the win if his teammates retake聽the lead the next time they鈥檙e at bat. Keep that in mind whenever President Trump talks (or writes) about health insurance premiums for Obamacare聽policies, which are sold to聽people not covered by a large employer鈥檚 group plan. (Jon Healey, 10/11)
There's been a lot of discussion of narrow provider networks and how they reduce costs by limiting access to the highest priced providers. They're commonplace in the Affordable Care Act marketplaces where about 10 million people are enrolled, and in the individual market generally 鈥 but聽they are actually quite rare in the group market, where about 152 million Americans get coverage through their employers. (Drew Altman, 10/12)
By the narrowest of margins, the U.S. Senate rejected legislation Wednesday that would have subjected patients with expensive illnesses to soaring premiums, canceled coverage and medical bankruptcy. You might expect such legislation to have been introduced by Republicans and defeated by Democrats, but you鈥檇 be wrong. Democrats sought to deny care to the sick. Republicans stopped them. (Michael F. Cannon, 10/11)
In Boston鈥檚 Jamaica Plain neighborhood, investments spurred by federal tax credits are turning into windows and walls. Soon will come stoves, pots and pans; then lunches and dinners; then healthier people, fewer hospital visits, lower health-care costs and jobs. But for federal New Markets Tax Credits (NMTCs), this trailblazing 鈥渇ood as medicine鈥 project 鈥 and many other important projects nationwide 鈥 may never happen. (Antony Bugg-Levine and Daniel Nissenbaum, 10/11)
The most audacious play in the 2018 election cycle is that the party that destroyed the American health insurance market is positioning itself as the savior of health care.And the most mind boggling piece is that the pitch seems to be selling. Democrats are managing to dump the mess they made of Obamacare fully in the laps of Republicans. Nearly聽all Democratic candidates聽are accusing their GOP opponents of stripping vulnerable Americans of health insurance, and setting themselves up as the defenders of the very system they ravaged.聽(Nolan Finley, 10/10)
ince the Affordable Care Act was signed into law in 2010, the percentage of uninsured Americans has dropped. Today, more than 20 million of us have access to health care thanks to the ACA and Medicaid expansion. That鈥檚 the good news. Unfortunately, millions of Americans are still uninsured. Last year alone, more than 2.6 million Floridians did not have the safety net of health insurance at one time or another. That鈥檚 nearly 13 percent of our population, a rate that tops the national average and ranks as the fifth highest in the country. (Dick Batchelor, 10/9)
Bernie Sanders, move over. Josh Hawley would like to get to your left on health care. Hawley, Missouri鈥檚 attorney general and Republican U.S. Senate candidate, would surely dispute that characterization. Yet Hawley鈥檚 latest explanation of how he would eliminate Obamacare while still covering people with pre-existing conditions sounds more like government-run health care than even what the socialist senator from Vermont has proposed. Hawley proposes to have the government collect people鈥檚 insurance premiums and pay their major medical costs once they鈥檝e reached a certain threshold. (10/8)
On Jan. 8, my husband, Josiah 鈥淪i鈥 Lewis went to Kaiser Oakland for a routine colonoscopy. During the procedure, the team lacerated his spleen without perforating his colon (it鈥檚 so rare for it to happen that it鈥檚 not listed on their Consent for Treatment form). They were unaware of the injury and sent him home with standard post-procedure instructions. By 5 p.m. Si was in such severe pain that I drove him to Kaiser鈥檚 emergency room. After several other tests, a CT scan showed bleeding from the spleen. (Alice Lewis, 10/11)