Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
Perspectives: Kavanaugh, Conservative Supreme Court Would Put Women's Reproductive Rights At Severe Risk
She has long prided herself on never missing a vote in the U.S. Senate. But of all the thousands she鈥檚 cast in her 21 years on Capitol Hill, this is the one on which Sen. Susan Collins鈥 legacy will hinge. She can vote later this month to confirm Brett Kavanaugh to the U.S. Supreme Court and hope 鈥 no, make that pray 鈥 that he stands by his assurance to her that Roe. v. Wade is 鈥渟ettled law.鈥 (Whatever that means.) Or she can open her eyes to what many others already see 鈥 that Kavanaugh represents the tipping point in the never-ending battle over a woman鈥檚 right to choose an abortion 鈥 and vote to keep him off the highest court in the land. (Bill Nemitz, 9/10)
(Brett) Kavanaugh鈥檚 obvious hostility to abortion rights is alarming, but it鈥檚 what President Trump promised and what Americans voted for in 2016. Yet that doesn鈥檛 mean senators should rubber-stamp iffy nominees for lifetime appointments. Start with Kavanaugh鈥檚 dissembling answer about abortion. It鈥檚 become standard for nominees to avoid commenting on their views on Roe v. Wade. It is not standard to mislead senators, but that鈥檚 just what Kavanaugh did. (9/10)
The first appointments were at 8 a.m., which had me on the road to my old, east-side neighborhood no later than 6:45. The clinic was on Eight Mile, closer to Kelly than Gratiot. You could easily miss the plain brick building with its windows tucked near the roofline. I sometimes did.聽Every Saturday, eight to 10聽of us gathered to escort unsuspecting women past the posters, prayers and pamphlets of anti-abortion activists. (Annmarie Erickson, 9/10)
It鈥檚 fitting that last week鈥檚 Kavanaugh confirmation hearings were regularly interrupted by the sound of women screaming. Again and again, protesters, most of them female, cried out for the preservation of their rights, and were arrested. Republican men were contemptuous. 鈥淲hat鈥檚 the hysteria coming from?鈥 asked Senator Ben Sasse of Nebraska. Let me answer. It is true, as Sasse said, that protesters have claimed for many years that if Roe v. Wade is overturned, women will die. It鈥檚 a fair prediction; women died before Roe, and where abortion is illegal, unsafe abortion leads to maternal death. In the past, however, Roe has been saved. Should Kavanaugh be confirmed, it will either fall or be eviscerated. (Michelle Goldberg, 9/10)