Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
If All Else Fails, Republicans May Turn To 'Skinny Plan' As Last Resort
If the current options for overhauling the health care system can鈥檛 get a majority of Senate votes, the majority leader, Mitch McConnell, has a new backup plan, according to senators and lobbyists: a simple bill that eliminates three of Obamacare鈥檚 least popular provisions. The plan, which has been nicknamed 鈥渟kinny repeal,鈥 would eliminate the Affordable Care Act鈥檚 individual mandate, the employer mandate and a tax on medical devices, at least for a few years. (Sanger-Katz, 7/25)
In substance, this plan would repeal just three parts of the ACA, according to several sources familiar with the approach. It would eliminate the requirement that most Americans carry health insurance as well as the requirement that employers with at least 50 full-time employees offer coverage to their workers. Both are central elements of the 2010 health-care law and its least popular aspects with the public. The 鈥渟kinny鈥 plan also would rescind the tax on medical devices, one of several taxes the ACA created to help pay for other elements of the law. A close variant of this surfaced two years ago in the House, as part of the GOP鈥檚 strategy back then to lower federal deficits. Congressional budget analysts estimated at the time that 15 million fewer Americans would have insurance coverage 鈥渕ost years鈥 as a result. (Goldstein, 7/25)
Experts warn, though, that repealing the individual mandate without any replacement measures would destabilize the insurance market and spike premiums. (Sullivan, 7/25)
The plan wouldn't touch Obamacare's Medicaid expansion, making it more palatable to Senate moderates. But it could trigger significant resistance by preserving the ACA's insurance regulations, which senators like Mike Lee of Utah and Rand Paul of Kentucky have insisted need to be struck down. "How do the ultra-conservatives vote for it?" asked one former Senate Republican aide. (Diamond, 7/25)
Moderates may be concerned the 鈥渄eath spiral鈥 would hurt too many people in the individual market. (Soffen and Schaul, 7/25)
Senate Republicans would likely go for a bare-minimum 鈥渟kinny repeal鈥 only if other approaches ... cannot win approval. (Abutaleb, 7/25)
There aren鈥檛 a lot of Colorado-specific numbers yet on the impacts of a repeal of the individual mandate, but there are two areas of concern in addition to rising costs.聽First, with more people uninsured, hospitals could be on the hook for providing more care that they don鈥檛 get paid for. That could聽threaten some hospitals鈥 ability to remain open.聽Second, if insurers are spooked by federal policy changes,聽they could bolt from the state as early as this year, leaving people shopping on their own for health insurance with fewer 鈥 or no 鈥 choices. (Ingold, 7/25)