吃瓜不打烊

Skip to main content

The independent source for health policy research, polling, and news.

Subscribe Follow Us
  • Trump 2.0

    Trump 2.0

    • Agency Watch
    • State Watch
    • Rural Health Payout
  • Public Health

    Public Health

    • Vaccines
    • CDC & Disease
    • Environmental Health
    All Public Health
  • Audio Reports

    Audio Reports

    • What the Health?
    • Healthcare Helpline
    • 吃瓜不打烊 Minute
    • An Arm and a Leg
    • Health Hub
    • HealthQ
    • Silence in Sikeston
    • Epidemic
    All Audio
  • Special Reports

    Special Reports

    • Bill Of The Month
    • Common Ground
    • Diagnosis: Debt
    • The Body Shops
    • Priced Out
    • Guns, Race, and Profit
    • Broken Rehab
    • Dead Zone
    • Denied
    • Opioid Settlement Tracking
    • Eleven Minutes
    All Special Reports
  • More Topics

    More Topics

    • Elections
    • Healthcare Costs
    • Insurance
    • Prescription Drugs
    • Health Industry
    • Immigration
    • Reproductive Health
    • Technology
    • Rural Health
    • Race and Health
    • Aging
    • Mental Health
    • Affordable Care Act
    • Medicare
    • Medicaid
    • Children’s Health
    All Topics

  • Medicare Advantage Billing Probe
  • School Vaccine Mandates
  • Weight Loss Drugs Coverage
  • Opioid Settlement Money
  • Abortion Pill Access

Morning Briefing

Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations

  • Email

Friday, May 5 2017

Full Issue

From 'Coming Up Short' To Victory: How Republican Leaders Gained The Final Votes

Six weeks ago, House Republicans could not muster enough votes to pass their health bill and pulled it from the floor. What happened to turn that failure around? Behind-the-scenes negotiations focused on amendments that could persuade the right-wing Freedom Caucus to back the legislation. In the end, Republicans wanted to deliver a win for President Donald Trump and on their pledge to repeal Obamacare.

The rescue effort that pulled the Republicans back from the brink of failure on health care began quietly, with two House members who are not exactly household names trying to find common ground on a little-noticed issue. They were Rep. Tom MacArthur (R-N.J.), a leader of the moderate House Republican bloc that calls itself the Tuesday Group, and Rep. Mark Meadows (R-N.C.), chairman of the conservative and hard-line House Freedom Caucus. The question at hand was giving states more flexibility by allowing them to come up with their own ways of achieving cost savings and providing coverage. (Tumulty and Costa, 5/4)

The House on Thursday squeaked out a one-vote win with the support of all but 20 Republicans, 15 of whom are members of the moderate Tuesday Group. No Democrats supported the bill. The path to 217, the ultimate tally of Republicans who supported the legislation, was fraught. House Republicans missed every deadline they set out for themselves to deliver the repeal of the health care law, a campaign promise they repeated for more than seven years. Leaders had to pull their first version of the legislation from floor consideration in March, when it became clear it lacked the support to pass. Since then, various groups of Republicans have been huddling in meetings like the one convened Monday, to work out policy changes that have bought anywhere from one to 30 votes. (Mershon and McPherson, 5/4)

As they raced toward Thursday鈥檚 vote on the American Health Care Act, House Republicans found themselves fending off ghosts. Seven years of attacks on the Affordable Care Act, seven years of insisting that the law had been jammed through without scrutiny, kept coming back to haunt them. First, they struggled to answer questions about the need to vote before the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) had estimated the costs of an amended AHCA. ... Next, they brushed off questions about whether they鈥檇 read the bill. (Weigel, 5/4)

For seven years, Republicans campaigned on a single message: Obamacare was rammed through Congress by power-hungry Democrats who rushed a hastily written bill riddled with backroom kickbacks. But now, after vowing for years that the repeal process would be different, with regular order and plenty of public scrutiny, Republicans are doing the exact same thing 鈥 or worse 鈥 that they blasted Democrats for repeatedly. Here鈥檚 how. (Caygle, 5/4)

Rep. Chris Collins (R-N.Y.), a top ally of President Trump, admitted Thursday he did not read the entire text of the GOP's healthcare bill that passed earlier in the day, but said his staff did. "I will fully admit, Wolf, I聽did not, but I can also assure you my聽staff did," Collins told host Wolf Blitzer on CNN's "The Situation Room." 聽(Beavers, 5/4)

Here's more on how the vote breaks down聽鈥

To get this version passed, Republican leaders positioned the bill far to the right of the political spectrum to win the support of most of the conservative House Freedom Caucus members and keep some moderates on board. And, that strategy worked. (Soffen, Cameron and Uhrmacher, 5/4)

A total of 19 hard-line conservatives associated with the Freedom Caucus, who expressed opposition or reservations to the original bill, voted 鈥測es鈥 on Thursday. These representatives, from the districts shown [on map], gave the revised bill enough votes to pass 鈥 the bill needed 216 鈥測es鈥 votes and received 217. (Bloch, Park and Pearce, 5/4)

Twenty mostly centrist House Republicans who represent swing districts voted against the GOP鈥檚 legislation to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act on Thursday. Two more defections would have doomed the bill, signaling how tough a vote it was for many lawmakers. Only one member of the conservative House Freedom Caucus, freshman Rep. Andy Biggs (R-Ariz.), voted against the measure because it didn鈥檛 go far enough to fully repeal the healthcare law. Two other libertarian-minded conservatives, Reps. Thomas Massie (Ky.) and Walter Jones (N.C.), also opposed it. (Marcos, 5/4)

Regional news outlets look at how their state聽delegations voted聽鈥

The U.S. House of Representatives voted 217-213聽Thursday afternoon to pass聽the latest Republican bill to repeal Obamacare. All three of Minnesota鈥檚 Republican representatives voted for the bill, while all five of Minnesota鈥檚 Democratic representatives voted against the bill. (5/4)

The House of Representatives voted Thursday to approve the American Health Care Act, touted by the GOP and President Donald Trump as a better alternative to President Obama's signature health care effort, the Affordable Care Act. ... KCUR reached out to House members from both Kansas and Missouri to get an idea of how the vote might shake out. (Rodriguez, Palmer and Spencer, 5/4)

The House Republicans鈥 victory on Thursday in passing a bill to repeal and replace 鈥淥bamacare鈥 couldn鈥檛 have happened without the unanimous support from the 14 members of California鈥檚 GOP congressional delegation. Those votes drew praise from some Californians convinced Obamacare has been a burden and must go.聽 But healthcare advocates around the state called the votes a stunning reversal 鈥 some said 鈥渂etrayal鈥 鈥 by several representatives who previously had cited serious concerns about the GOP legislation, which was opposed by all 39 House Democrats. (Seipel, 5/4)

The 14 Republicans in California鈥檚 House delegation helped give their party its biggest victory to date Thursday in its seven-year campaign against the Affordable Care Act, voting to gut the law in defiance of Democratic threats to have them 鈥渢attooed鈥 with the decision come next year鈥檚 elections. The state鈥檚 GOP contingent voted unanimously for a Republican bill to replace the health-insurance law commonly known as Obamacare, including seven members who represent districts that President Trump lost in November. (Lochhead, 5/4)

Arizona conservatives were largely on board Thursday with the House's passage of the American Health Care Act, a move that revived Republican hopes of repealing central parts of President Barack Obama's signature health-care law. Freshman Rep. Andy Biggs, who represents a conservative congressional district east of Phoenix, was the only Arizona Republican to vote against the legislation, joining Democratic Reps. Ruben Gallego, Raul Grijalva, Tom O'Halleran and Kyrsten Sinema in opposing the bill. (Nowicki, 5/4)

Three of Iowa鈥檚 four members of Congress on Thursday voted in favor of a bill repealing major elements of the health care law known as Obamacare. All three of Iowa鈥檚 Republican members 鈥 U.S. Reps. Rod Blum, Steve King and David Young 鈥 voted for the GOP-led legislation, the American Health Care Act. Iowa鈥檚 lone Democrat in the House, U.S. Rep. Dave Loebsack, voted against the bill. (Noble, 5/4)

This is part of the Morning Briefing, a summary of health policy coverage from major news organizations. Sign up for an email subscription.
Newsletter icon

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Stay informed by signing up for the Morning Briefing and other emails:

Recent Morning Briefings

  • Today, August 3
  • Friday, July 31
  • Thursday, July 30
  • Wednesday, July 29
  • Tuesday, July 28
  • Monday, July 27
More Morning Briefings
RSS Feeds
  • Podcasts
  • Special Reports
  • Morning Briefing
  • 吃瓜不打烊
  • Republish Our Content
  • Contact Us

Follow Us

  • RSS

Sign up for emails

Join our email list for regular updates based on your personal preferences.

Sign up
  • Editorial Policy
  • Privacy Policy

漏 2026 KFF