Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
Different Takes: Lessons On The Health Law's Success In Cost Control; Bernie's Onto Something About Women Being Better Off Giving Birth In Finland
Even before the Affordable Care Act became law, about 90 percent of the conversation and criticism of it was about coverage. Little has been said about its ability to control costs. March 23, the ninth anniversary of the ACA鈥檚 passage, presents a good opportunity to examine its legacy on cost control 鈥 a legacy that deserves to be in the foreground, not relegated to the background behind the exchanges, Medicaid expansion, and work requirements. (Ezekiel J. Emanuel, 3/22)
A few years ago, personal finance writer Ester Bloom, faced with a four-figure health-insurance deductible and a narrow network of doctors to choose from, attempted to price out how much giving birth to her younger child would cost her. It turned out to be an all but impossible task. I thought about Bloom on Wednesday, when reviewing a Twitter dispute between Bernie Sanders and former Trump administration official Nikki Haley over the high cost of giving birth in the United States. (Helaine Olen, 3/21)
A doctor concludes that an elderly patient has less than six months to live. A second doctor disagrees. One of the predictions will be wrong. But was it false? For two years, the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has wrestled with this question. The decision could ratify a trend of criminalizing medical judgments and jailing doctors based on disagreements with other doctors. (Kyle Clark and Andrew George, 3/21)
We鈥檙e now in the silly season of the Democratic primary 鈥 a season that, I worry, may last all the way to the nomination. There are many honorable exceptions, but an awful lot of reporting seems to be third order 鈥 not about the candidates, let alone their policy proposals, but about pundits鈥 views about voters鈥 views of candidates鈥 electability. It鈥檚 a discussion in which essentially nobody has any idea what he or she is talking about. Meanwhile, however, there are some real continuing policy debates. (Paul Krugman, 3/21)
Rules proposed by the Trump administration depend on physicians performing 鈥渆xams鈥 to spot immigrants who are sick enough to become reliant on the government for living costs. The impact would be devastating for immigrants who are denied visas. (Khameer Kidia, 3/20)
The future health of those 鈥渞eal people鈥 now rests in the hands of the Kansas Senate and Senate President Susan Wagle, a Republican. Wagle is an opponent of Medicaid expansion. Surely, though, the vote in the Kansas House is enough to convince her and other senators that expansion should at least get a vote in their chamber. (3/21)