Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
Debunking A 19th Century Myth: Humans Actually Have A Great Sense Of Smell
We鈥檝e been led to believe that our sense of smell is sadly deficient compared with our mammalian cousins such as rodents and dogs. What does the world smell like to a bloodhound, we might wonder. What scents 鈥 glorious or gross 鈥 can a twitchy little mouse nose detect that are passing right by us. You can stop wondering because it turns out that our sense of smell is not so bad after all. (Netburn, 5/11)
Smell, the thinking goes, is not our strongest sense. Our lowly noses are eclipsed by our ability to see the world around us, hear the sound of music and feel the touch of a caress. Even animals, we're taught, have a far more acute sense of smell than we do. But one scientist argues the idea of an inferior sense of smell stems from a 19th-century myth. (Harris, 5/11)
In a review published Thursday in the journal Science,聽John McGann, a professor of psychology at Rutgers University in New Jersey, argued that this is a聽flawed perception dating back to the 19th century. He blamed pioneering French anatomist Paul Broca, who wrote that, given the comparatively small olfactory organs in the primate brain,聽鈥渋t is no longer the sense of smell that guides the animal.鈥 As for smelling in apes, humans included,聽鈥淎ll that exceeded the needs of this聽humble function became useless.鈥 (Guarino, 5/11)